Understand in about 6 minutes
Tolstoy argues that the command not to resist evil by force is the substance of Christ's teaching, that church and state alike rest on the violence it forbids, and that the order of force dissolves as individuals refuse to take part in it.
Mind Map
Core Message
Tolstoy takes the Sermon on the Mount's command not to resist evil by force in its direct sense and treats it as the point on which Christianity stands or falls. A minority has professed it since the faith began, from the Quakers to Garrison and Ballou, and he finds that critics of every kind evade the command rather than answer it.
The churches put creeds and ceremonies in the place of the Sermon on the Mount, and governments hold power through prisons, executions, and armies. Tolstoy concludes that true Christianity, a doctrine of meekness and love, cannot recognize either institution, because each is held together by the violence Christ renounced.
Against churchmen and men of science alike, the book presents Christ's teaching as the third of three conceptions of life. Beyond living for oneself and living for tribe or state comes the divine conception, in which life means serving God through love. Its commandments are signposts toward an ideal of never using force, and the ideal is not to be lowered to fit existing habits.
No revolution can break the circle of state violence, since force only renews it. The single freedom granted to anyone is to recognize and profess the truth, and each man who declines the oath, the tax, or the rifle on Christian grounds undermines government more surely than any conspiracy, until a new public opinion carries the rest.
Summary
The Kingdom of God Is Within You grew out of the response to Tolstoy's earlier confession of faith, What I Believe. The letters and books that reached him afterward showed that the command of nonresistance to evil by force had been professed by a minority since Christianity began: by the Quakers, by William Lloyd Garrison's declaration of 1838, by Adin Ballou, who spent fifty years preaching the doctrine, and by Helchitsky, a fifteenth-century Czech whose Net of Faith made the same case. Each witness had been ignored or hushed up, and Tolstoy's own critics, religious and secular, evaded the question instead of answering it.
Tolstoy then asks why so simple a teaching stays invisible. Believers receive Christianity from churches that substituted creeds, ceremonies, and obedience for the Sermon on the Mount, while educated men dismiss the faith as an outlived superstition without examining its content. Both are certain they already understand it, and a mind persuaded that it knows cannot take in even the plainest words of the Gospel.
At the book's center stand three conceptions of life. The animal man lives for his own desires; the pagan or social man lives for tribe, family, and state; the Christian lives for God, the source of life, and his law is love. Christ's commandments are not statutes but signposts marking the level below which one need not fall, and the fourth names the ideal of never using force for any purpose. Modern Europe carries this Christian consciousness inside a pagan order, and the contradiction runs through property, courts, and diplomacy to its furthest limit in universal military service, which asks every citizen to stand ready to kill at command.
Force cannot resolve the contradiction. Eighteen centuries have shown that no definition of evil can bind everyone, and government power forms a closed circle of four methods: intimidation, corruption, the hypnotizing of the people from childhood, and the conscription of stupefied young men as soldiers who then enforce the rest. Revolution only re-arms the circle. The way out is the one Christ proposed: the man who accepts the divine conception of life obeys God rather than men, endures violence without joining it, and becomes free. Like bees that can leave the cluster only one at a time, individuals who quietly refuse oaths, taxes, police duty, and army service dissolve the state's power from within, and governments dread them more than conspirators, since punishing them only publishes the principle they stand on.
The conclusion turns from argument to witness. While finishing the book, Tolstoy's train passed another carrying a governor, soldiers, and rods to flog starving peasants over a landowner's forest, and he asks how ordinary, kindly men can do such work. His answer is the hypnotism of state service, responsibility divided until no one feels it, and the twin intoxications of power and servility. The remedy he leaves is not a program but repentance. The kingdom of God comes not with outward show; it is within, and it arrives as each person stops lying about his life and professes the truth he already sees.
Key Concepts
The Sermon on the Mount's command taken in its direct sense: a Christian may never use violence, whatever evil he faces, and so may not fight, punish, or compel. Tolstoy treats it as the commandment that holds Christ's whole teaching together.
It is the test the book applies to everything. A church or a government that blesses war and executions has, on this standard, given up Christianity while keeping its name.
All conduct rests on one of three views of life: the individual conception, which lives for personal desire; the social or pagan conception, which lives for tribe, family, and state; and the divine conception, which lives for God, the source of life, through love.
It explains the misery of the age as a transition. Men who have inwardly outgrown the social conception still keep its institutions, and the pain of that mismatch is what pushes humanity toward the Christian view.
Government holds men by four linked methods: intimidation through punishment, corruption that pays officials out of the people's taxes, hypnotism that schools and churches work on conscience from childhood, and the conscription of young men whom drill turns into obedient instruments.
Because the four links close into a ring, force cannot break it; the soldiers produced at the end enforce the other three. The book's case for refusal rather than revolution rests on this analysis.
Mental Models
Men caught in the state conception of life are like bees hanging in a cluster from a branch. The swarm cannot fly off all at once; it moves only when one bee spreads her wings, then another, until the inert cluster becomes a flying swarm.
It answers the objection that personal refusal is too slow. Waiting for a collective solution keeps everyone hanging, and the only general change is the kind that begins with single persons.
Christ gives an ideal of perfection, such as never using force for any purpose, and precepts that mark the level below which one need not fall on the way to it. The precept is a signpost on an endless road, not the destination.
It dissolves the claim that the teaching is impracticable. A direction cannot be impracticable, and the ideal is never to be lowered to match existing conduct.
The strongest current of water cannot add a drop to a cup that is already full. A man persuaded that he understands a teaching cannot take in even its simplest words, while a slower mind without preconceptions can.
It explains why believers and scholars alike miss the Gospel's plain sense, and warns the reader to ask whether certainty, not evidence, is doing the resisting.
Selected Quotes
Christianity in its true sense puts an end to government.
The most difficult subjects can be explained to the most slow-witted man if he has not formed any idea of them already; but the simplest thing cannot be made clear to the most intelligent man if he is firmly persuaded that he knows already, without a shadow of doubt, what is laid before him.
There is one thing, and only one thing, in which it is granted to you to be free in life, all else being beyond your power: that is to recognize and profess the truth.
Source
Source text: Project Gutenberg edition of The Kingdom of God Is Within You by Leo Tolstoy, translated by Constance Garnett.
HTML text: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/43302/pg43302.txt
Project Gutenberg states that this ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions.
Tolstoy dated his preface from Yasnaya Polyana in May 1893. Constance Garnett's English translation was published in 1894 by the Cassell Publishing Co. of New York, with the subtitle Christianity Not as a Mystic Religion but as a New Theory of Life.